7 Engagement Ring Myths You Probably Still Believe

When it comes to engagement rings, there’s no shortage of myths and misconceptions. Whether passed down through generations or fueled by clever marketing, these myths can lead to unnecessary stress and confusion when choosing the perfect ring.
From the idea that diamonds are the only option to outdated beliefs about spending three months’ salary, we’re here to debunk these common engagement ring myths. Let’s dive into the truth behind the sparkle!
Myth #1: You Must Spend Three Months’ Salary
One of the most well-known engagement ring myths is that you must spend three months’ salary. This rule originated from a marketing campaign by diamond companies—not from any cultural or financial necessity.
The Truth:
- There’s no set amount you must spend on an engagement ring. Your budget should align with your financial situation and priorities.
- Many couples today prioritize experiences, homeownership, or future investments over an expensive ring.
- Custom and alternative rings allow for stunning, budget-friendly options.
Myth #2: Diamonds Are the Only Option
Diamonds have long been the traditional choice for engagement rings, but that doesn’t mean they’re the only—or best—option.
The Truth:
- Moissanite, sapphires, and other gemstones offer unique and stunning alternatives at a fraction of the cost.
- Colored gemstones are growing in popularity, allowing couples to choose a ring that truly represents their style.
- Lab-grown diamonds provide an ethical and budget-friendly alternative to mined diamonds.
Myth #3: The Bigger the Diamond, the Better the Ring
Many people believe that a larger diamond means a better-quality ring, but size isn’t everything.
The Truth:
- A diamond’s quality depends on the 4Cs: Cut, Color, Clarity, and Carat weight.
- A well-cut smaller diamond can appear more brilliant than a larger, poorly cut one.
- Personal preference matters—some people prefer dainty, minimalist designs over large statement rings.
Myth #4: Custom Rings Are Too Expensive
Many couples assume that designing a custom engagement ring is beyond their budget.
The Truth:
- Custom rings can be more affordable than pre-designed options, especially when choosing alternative gemstones or unique settings.
- You have control over every detail, allowing you to create a meaningful piece that fits your budget.
- Many jewelers offer flexible pricing and payment plans.
Explore custom ring options at Liana Lifestyle.
Myth #5: You Must Buy a Brand-Name Ring
Some believe that only big-name jewelry brands offer high-quality engagement rings.
The Truth:
- Independent jewelers often provide better quality and customization options at a lower price.
- Brand-name rings come with significant markups, mainly due to marketing and packaging.
- Shopping from local or ethical jewelers allows for more unique and personal selections.
Myth #6: Engagement Rings Must Be New
Many assume an engagement ring must be brand new to be meaningful.
The Truth:
- Vintage and heirloom rings carry sentimental value and unique craftsmanship.
- Reusing a family ring can be a sustainable and cost-effective option.
- Many jewelers specialize in restoring and resizing vintage rings for a modern touch.
Check out sustainable and vintage jewelry ideas at Liana Lifestyle.
Myth #7: Your Partner Should Choose the Ring Alone
Tradition often suggests that the proposal should be a complete surprise, including the ring choice.
The Truth:
- Many couples today shop for rings together to ensure they get the perfect style and fit.
- A surprise proposal can still be romantic with input on ring preferences.
- Some couples opt for placeholder rings and choose the final ring together later.
Conclusion
Choosing an engagement ring is a deeply personal experience, and you shouldn’t let outdated myths dictate your decision. Whether you opt for a traditional diamond, a unique gemstone, or a vintage piece, the most important factor is that it reflects your love and commitment.