5 Bible Journaling Mistakes to Avoid as a Newbie (And What to Do Instead)

|

Bible journaling is a powerful way to connect more deeply with Scripture, reflect on your faith, and grow spiritually. Whether you’re a creative soul or someone just exploring new ways to study God’s Word, this practice can add beauty and intention to your quiet time.

But if you’re new to it, you might find yourself overwhelmed or unsure where to begin. The truth is, many beginners make the same common mistakes that can lead to burnout, comparison, or even a disconnection from the purpose behind journaling in the first place.

In this post, we’ll uncover the 5 most common Bible journaling mistakes newbies make, and more importantly, how to avoid them so you can build a life-giving journaling routine that nourishes your faith.

Mistake #1: Focusing Too Much on Aesthetics

It’s easy to get swept up by the gorgeous Bible journal spreads on Pinterest or Instagram. But when the goal becomes making your pages look good rather than engaging with Scripture, you lose the heart of the practice.

Why This Happens

Newbies often compare their work to experienced journalers and feel like theirs isn’t “good enough.” This can discourage you from starting or cause unnecessary stress during your devotional time.

What to Do Instead:

  • Keep it simple. Start with a pen and highlighter. Add creativity later if it feels right.
  • Focus on Scripture first. Let your reflection on God’s Word guide what (or if) you illustrate.
  • Remember: This is worship, not art class.

Mistake #2: Thinking You Need Expensive Supplies

You don’t need a stack of washi tapes, watercolor kits, or fancy calligraphy pens to start Bible journaling. This misconception often leads beginners to spend money they don’t need to or feel like they can’t start without a full “haul.”

Budget-Friendly Alternatives

  • A simple notebook or journaling Bible is enough.
  • Use what you have at home: pens, colored pencils, sticky notes.
  • Free printables or digital templates can be useful tools to get started.

Tip: Start with minimal tools. As you grow in the practice, you’ll naturally figure out what supplies genuinely support your journaling style.

Save
Pin for later? 📌

Mistake #3: Overcomplicating the Process

Trying to follow strict rules or create the perfect layout can steal the joy and spiritual connection out of Bible journaling. Some people treat it like a performance instead of a personal, grace-filled expression.

How to Simplify Your Approach

  • Begin with a short Scripture passage.
  • Ask three simple questions: What does this mean? What is God saying to me? How can I apply it?
  • Jot down your thoughts, prayers, or observations—no fancy formatting needed.

You don’t have to fill every page or match a theme. Let your journaling flow organically from your time with God.

Mistake #4: Journaling Without Intention

Journaling just to “keep up” or fill pages can make the practice feel like a chore. Without intention, Bible journaling becomes a task rather than a spiritual discipline.

Create Purposeful Journaling Moments

  • Set a specific goal before each journaling session. Is it to reflect, to pray, or to understand?
  • Choose a Bible reading plan or follow a devotional theme.
  • Reflect on how the Scripture speaks to your current season.

Let every entry come from a place of personal engagement, not obligation.

Mistake #5: Comparing Your Journey to Others

Comparison is a trap that steals joy. Whether it’s your writing style, artwork, or the depth of your spiritual reflections—it’s easy to feel like others are doing it “better.”

Reclaiming Confidence in Your Own Faith Walk

  • Bible journaling is your sacred time with God.
  • There is no right or wrong way to journal.
  • Celebrate small wins and personal insights—those are what truly matter.

Try to view other journalers’ pages as inspiration, not competition.

Conclusion

Bible journaling should be a life-giving, soul-nourishing practice—not a pressure-filled performance. As a beginner, it’s perfectly okay to start small, be messy, and grow over time. The most important part isn’t how your pages look—but how your heart connects with God through His Word.

Here’s a quick recap of what to avoid:

  • Don’t focus only on aesthetics.
  • Don’t assume you need fancy tools.
  • Don’t make it more complicated than it needs to be.
  • Don’t journal without intention.
  • Don’t compare your journey to someone else’s.

Instead, stay rooted in grace. Let your journal be a reflection of a living, growing faith—not a polished masterpiece.

Similar Posts