4 Engagement Ring Myths You Should Stop Believing Right Now

The moment someone mentions engagement rings, a swirl of traditions, expectations, and myths come to mind. From the supposed “three-month salary rule” to the idea that diamonds are the only choice, many misconceptions surround this special piece of jewelry. But how much of what you’ve heard is actually true?
In this post, we’ll debunk four common engagement ring myths so you can make an informed and stress-free decision when choosing the perfect ring.
Myth #1: You Must Spend Three Months’ Salary on an Engagement Ring
One of the most persistent engagement ring myths is that you must spend three months’ worth of your salary on a ring. This “rule” was actually a marketing campaign created by diamond companies decades ago to boost sales.
The Reality
- There’s no set amount you need to spend on a ring—it all depends on your personal budget and preferences.
- Many couples today prioritize experiences or financial goals over expensive jewelry.
- Some of the most stunning engagement rings come in all price ranges, with many affordable yet high-quality options available.
Smart Spending Tips
- Set a realistic budget based on your financial situation.
- Consider alternative gemstones or lab-grown diamonds for more affordability.
- Focus on the 4Cs (Cut, Clarity, Color, Carat) to get the best value for your money.
Myth #2: Diamonds Are the Only Acceptable Stone for Engagement Rings
For decades, diamonds have dominated the engagement ring industry, leading many to believe they’re the only acceptable choice.
The Reality
- Diamonds gained popularity due to strategic marketing, not necessity.
- Other gemstones like sapphires, emeralds, and morganite offer unique beauty and meaning.
- Celebrities and trendsetters are increasingly choosing non-diamond rings, making alternative stones more mainstream.
Popular Alternatives
- Sapphires – Durable and available in a variety of colors.
- Emeralds – Symbolic of love and rebirth.
- Morganite – A soft pink stone that exudes romance.
- Moissanite – A brilliant, affordable diamond alternative.
Myth #3: The Bigger the Diamond, the Better
Many people assume that a bigger diamond automatically means a better ring, but size isn’t everything.
The Reality
- A well-cut diamond will sparkle more than a larger but poorly cut stone.
- Balance is key—rings should be proportionate to the wearer’s hand and style preferences.
- A smaller, high-quality diamond can look more stunning than a large, lower-quality one.
What to Prioritize Instead
- Cut: The most important factor for brilliance and sparkle.
- Clarity & Color: Choose a balance that suits your budget.
- Setting & Style: A beautiful setting can enhance a smaller diamond’s appearance.
Myth #4: You Must Buy a Brand-New Engagement Ring
Many believe that an engagement ring must be brand-new to be special, but that’s simply not true.
The Reality
- Heirloom and vintage rings carry sentimental and historical value.
- Buying second-hand or vintage can be more sustainable and budget-friendly.
- Customizing a pre-owned ring allows you to create something truly unique.
Where to Find Unique Rings
- Antique jewelry stores or estate sales.
- Online marketplaces specializing in pre-owned luxury jewelry.
- Family heirlooms that can be restored or customized.
Conclusion
Engagement rings are deeply personal, and there are no rigid rules you must follow when choosing one. By debunking these four common myths, you can focus on what truly matters—finding a ring that represents your love and fits your unique style and budget.